My first time was when I was in elementary school with a college girl that lived in my neighborhood.

She was gorgeous and my role model.

One day she said "Wanna come over?" and I followed her happily. I ate dinner there, took a bath with her... And in the bathtub she held my chin in her hand and asked "Can I?" with a serious look on her face. It says where she put her hand but I have no idea how to read that. -It says "ago" (chin). What I imagine after reading that line is the older girl propping up the younger girl's chin with her index and middle fingers to position her for a kiss. Not written with such detail so I just changed your translation a bit.

And I said, "Yes."... That was my first kiss. From there we rolled into bed and made love until morning.

That was the first night I pulled an all-nighter as well.